top of page
Search

Can You Put a Metal Roof Over Shingles? What Utah Homeowners Should Know

Oct 15
8 min read

If you're thinking about upgrading to a metal roof, you might be wondering if you can skip the hassle of removing your old shingles. After all, tearing off an existing roof takes time, creates a lot of debris, and adds to the overall cost of your project.


So, can you put a metal roof over shingles?


Yes, you can sometimes install a metal roof over existing asphalt shingles. However, it depends on the condition of your current roof, local building codes, and the type of metal roofing system you're installing.


For Utah homeowners, there are a few additional things to consider, especially with our heavy snow, intense summer heat, and changing temperatures.


Let's look at when installing metal roofing over shingles makes sense, the potential drawbacks, and why removing your old roof might be the better investment.

Can You Install a Metal Roof Over Existing Shingles?

In many cases, installing a metal roof over one existing layer of asphalt shingles is possible. This process is called a roof overlay or roof recover.


Rather than removing the old shingles, roofing contractors install an approved metal roofing system over the existing roof. Depending on the product, this may involve protective underlayment, specialized attachment methods, or a supporting framework.


However, there are some important requirements.


  • Your existing shingles need to be in good condition. Severely damaged, deteriorating, or water soaked roofing materials can create problems for the new roof.

  • Your roof structure needs to support the installation. Even though metal roofing is relatively lightweight, the combined weight and installation loads still matter.

  • Local building codes must allow it. Roofing regulations vary by location and may restrict installing new materials over existing layers.

  • The metal roofing manufacturer must approve the installation method. Some products require specific underlayment, fasteners, or a complete removal of existing materials.


A professional metal roofing contractor in Utah can inspect your roof and determine which installation method makes the most sense.


Benefits of Putting a Metal Roof Over Shingles

Installing metal roofing over existing shingles can offer several advantages when your roof qualifies for an overlay.


1. Lower Installation Costs

One of the biggest reasons homeowners consider a metal roof overlay is the potential cost savings.


Removing shingles requires additional labor, disposal fees, and time. If your existing roof is in good condition, leaving the shingles in place may reduce some of those expenses.

However, any required framing, additional materials, or roof preparation can offset those savings.


2. Faster Installation

Skipping the tear off process can reduce the amount of time needed to complete your roofing project.


For homeowners who want to minimize disruption, this can be a major benefit.

The actual timeline depends on your roof's size, design, condition, and the installation method.


3. Less Roofing Waste

A typical roof replacement can produce a significant amount of waste from old shingles, nails, and other roofing materials.


Installing metal roofing over shingles means fewer materials need to be removed and transported to a landfill.


That can make an overlay appealing for homeowners looking to reduce construction waste.


4. Long Lasting Metal Roofing Performance

Metal roofing offers several benefits that make it attractive for Utah homes.

These include excellent weather resistance, relatively low maintenance, and a lifespan that can extend several decades with proper installation.


If you're planning to stay in your home for years, upgrading to metal roofing can be a worthwhile investment.


You can learn more in our guide on how long a metal roof lasts in Utah.


Potential Problems With Installing Metal Roofing Over Shingles

While installing a metal roof over shingles sounds convenient, there are some drawbacks worth considering.


Hidden Roof Damage

One of the biggest concerns with a roof overlay is that you can't fully inspect the roof decking underneath the old shingles.


If your roof has hidden moisture damage, rotting wood, or other structural problems, those issues could remain unnoticed.


Over time, they may compromise the performance of your new roofing system.

Removing the old shingles gives contractors direct access to the decking so they can identify and repair problems before installing new materials.


Uneven Roofing Surfaces

Older shingles don't always create a smooth, even surface.


If they're curling, buckling, or deteriorating, installing metal panels directly over them can create problems with how the new roof fits and performs.


Some roofing systems use approved support structures to address uneven surfaces, but these need to be designed and installed correctly.


Added Weight

Metal roofing is generally lighter than many other roofing materials, but installing it over shingles still adds weight to your existing roof.


That becomes especially important in Utah communities that experience heavy snowfall.

Your roof must be capable of supporting the complete roofing system along with expected snow loads.


Moisture and Ventilation Concerns

Moisture management is an important part of any roofing installation.

Improper underlayment, flashing, or ventilation can allow moisture to accumulate, potentially contributing to mold, wood deterioration, and other damage.


A properly designed metal roofing system needs appropriate water protection and ventilation, regardless of how it's installed.


Warranty and Building Code Restrictions

Some metal roofing manufacturers have specific requirements for installing their products over existing shingles.


Failing to follow those instructions can affect warranty coverage.


Local building codes may also limit the number of roofing layers or prohibit overlays under certain conditions.


That's why it's important to have a roofing contractor review the requirements before starting your project.


Is It Better to Remove Shingles Before Installing a Metal Roof?

For many Utah homeowners, removing the old shingles before installing a metal roof is the better long term choice.


A complete roof replacement allows contractors to inspect the decking, address hidden damage, and build the new roofing system on a properly prepared surface.


Here are some situations where removing the existing shingles is especially important:


  • Your roof has experienced recurring leaks or water damage.

  • Shingles are curling, cracking, or missing.

  • There's visible sagging or deterioration.

  • Your roof already has multiple layers of roofing.

  • The existing roof is near the end of its lifespan.

  • Your chosen metal roofing system requires a complete tear off.


Although removing the old shingles increases the upfront cost, it gives you a better opportunity to identify problems before they become expensive repairs.


At J.B. Reliable Roofing, our roof replacement services include inspecting existing roofing conditions and helping homeowners choose the right materials and installation approach.


How Is Metal Roofing Installed Over Shingles?

If your roof qualifies for a metal roofing overlay, the process generally involves several steps.


Step 1: Inspecting the Existing Roof

Before any work begins, a roofing contractor evaluates the condition of your shingles and looks for signs of moisture damage, structural problems, or ventilation issues.

They'll also determine if the roof meets local building code requirements.


Step 2: Preparing the Roof Surface

The existing roof may need repairs or adjustments before new materials can be installed.

Depending on the system, preparation may involve approved underlayment, specialized attachment components, or another manufacturer approved approach.


Step 3: Installing the Metal Roofing System

The contractor installs the metal panels using fastening methods designed for the specific product and underlying roof structure.


Proper fastening is especially important in Utah, where strong winds and winter storms can put significant stress on roofing materials.


Step 4: Installing Flashing and Finishing Details

Roof flashing helps direct water away from vulnerable areas, including chimneys, vents, valleys, and roof edges.


The contractor also completes ventilation details, trim, and other components needed to create a weather resistant system.


Step 5: Final Inspection

Once the installation is complete, the roof should be inspected to ensure everything is properly secured and installed according to applicable requirements.


For additional information about roofing standards, homeowners can review the International Residential Code's roof assembly requirements.


Is Putting Metal Roofing Over Shingles a Good Idea in Utah?

Utah's climate makes roof installation decisions particularly important.

Between summer temperatures, winter snowfall, and seasonal storms, your roofing system needs to handle a wide range of weather conditions.


Here are a few factors Utah homeowners should consider.


Heavy Snow and Ice

Metal roofs are popular in snowy climates because many systems allow snow to slide off more easily than traditional asphalt shingles.


However, snow sliding from metal roofing can create hazards near walkways, driveways, and entrances. Snow retention systems may be needed in certain locations.

Your roof also needs to be designed for the expected snow loads in your area.


Hot Summers

Metal roofing can help reflect solar heat, particularly when installed with reflective finishes.

That can reduce the amount of heat absorbed by your roof during Utah's hot summers.

The overall energy performance depends on the roof's color, insulation, ventilation, and installation.


Temperature Changes

Utah's changing temperatures cause roofing materials to expand and contract.

Metal roofing systems are designed to accommodate thermal movement, but proper fastening and installation are essential.


An experienced contractor can recommend materials that work well with Utah's climate and your home's roof design.


For homeowners comparing options, our guide to the best roofing materials for Utah homes is a helpful place to start.


How Much Does It Cost to Put a Metal Roof Over Shingles?

The cost of installing metal roofing over existing shingles depends on several factors, including:


  • The size and slope of your roof

  • The type of metal roofing material

  • The complexity of your roof design

  • The condition of your existing shingles

  • Required underlayment or support materials

  • Flashing, ventilation, and other installation requirements

  • Local labor and permit costs


A metal roof overlay may cost less than a complete tear off and replacement, but the difference varies from project to project.


For example, a roof requiring extensive preparation or a specialized support system may offer limited savings compared to removing the shingles.


Getting a professional roof inspection and comparing both installation options is the best way to understand the potential costs.


Upgrade Your Utah Home With J.B. Reliable Roofing

If you're considering metal roofing, the first step is finding out what your current roof needs.

At J.B. Reliable Roofing, we help Utah homeowners choose roofing materials and installation methods that make sense for their homes, budgets, and long term goals.

With more than 24 years of roofing experience, our team understands the challenges Utah roofs face throughout the year.


We offer professional metal roof installation, repairs, and replacements, along with honest recommendations about the condition of your existing roof.


Thinking about putting a metal roof over shingles? Contact J.B. Reliable Roofing to schedule an inspection and get a quote for your roofing project.


Frequently Asked Questions About Installing Metal Roofing Over Shingles


Can you put a metal roof over two layers of shingles?

Generally, no. Model residential building codes commonly prohibit roof overlays when the existing roof already has two or more layers. Local code requirements and approved roofing system details determine what's allowed for your home.


Do you need underlayment when installing a metal roof over shingles?

Many metal roofing systems require approved underlayment or a specific separation assembly. The exact requirements depend on the manufacturer's instructions and the roofing system being installed.


Will shingles rot under a metal roof?

Existing shingles don't automatically rot when covered by metal roofing. However, trapped moisture, damaged decking, or improper installation can lead to deterioration. That's why inspecting the existing roof and designing proper moisture protection are important.


Can you install a standing seam metal roof over shingles?

Some standing seam metal roofing systems can be installed over existing shingles using manufacturer approved methods. The roof must meet structural, code, and installation requirements.


Is a metal roof over shingles as good as a complete roof replacement?

A properly designed overlay can perform well, but a complete tear off allows contractors to inspect and repair the roof deck before installing the new system. For older or damaged roofs, removing the shingles is often the more reliable option.


How long does a metal roof last over shingles?

Metal roofs commonly last 40 to 70 years, depending on the material, environment, and installation quality. An overlay's lifespan also depends on the condition of the underlying roof and whether the complete system was installed correctly.

 
 
 

Comments


Utah's Trusted Roofing Experts – Serving the Entire Beehive State

FOLLOW US

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Tel: (385) 424 - 7736

Opening Hours: 7am - 7pm
Email: info@jbreliableroofing.com

bottom of page